(239) 649-8050

Call Us For a Free Consultation.


Visits by Appointment.



Deficiency Judgement

Foreclosure and deficiency judgments

Foreclosure and deficiency judgments often go hand-in-hand after the loss of a home through foreclosure. The loss of one’s home to foreclosure is often times financially devastating and personally humiliating. But the problems may not stop when the foreclosure process is completed at the auction sale or even if the lender accepts a deed in lieu of foreclosure.


The lender has additional expenses from the foreclosure and for selling a property to a retail buyer after they get it back at the auction. These expenses include the obvious costs associated with the foreclosure including attorneys’ fees, lost interest, solution of liens on the property not discharged at the auction, and when it is sold, the Realtor commissions, maintenance, taxes, utilities, closing costs, etc.


The larger loss that can’t be passed on to the former homeowner is the loss of the lender’s lending ability, and resultant income, because of Federal Reserve cash reserve requirements for the foreclosed property.


This loss of lending ability is the reason lenders do not want take homes back from foreclosures auctions unless these properties can be sold quickly for a profit. The lender can easily calculate a “final loss” amount that the court system will validate or grant as a “deficiency judgment” against the former homeowner. Once awarded a deficiency judgment the lender can now start the process to seize assets such as your car and money in bank accounts, along with garnishing your wages until their loss has been repaid.


For accounting or legal considerations, the lender may choose to report the loan deficiency for the guarantor on Form 1099 to the IRS. This gives the former homeowner or loan guarantor a “phantom income” equal to the amount of the loan deficiency and will require he pay income taxes on this amount. In this case, the cost of the guarantor’s foreclosure will be the amount of income taxes he pays the IRS instead of the entire amount of the deficiency judgment plus additional interest and expenses. This can be substantial savings to the homeowner and the lender benefits because of a better impact to their financial statement.


If a lender accepts a deed in lieu of foreclosure and they make a profit from its sale, they will retain the profit. However, if they lose money, they may be able to issue a 1099 depending on the terms of the original loan agreement and the Acceptance Agreement. It is always wise to have an attorney review any agreement before you sign it to preserve your financial interests. Have the terms of your loan agreement reviewed and any agreements a lender offers you.


The foreclosure laws in Florida are changing almost daily. Not everyone will qualify for a loan reinstatement which is why it’s important to consult with qualified loss mitigation professionals. Remember, banks are going to do what’s in their best interest, not yours! Naples attorneys, Marc L. Shapiro, P.A. can help put a package together that helps banks understand why it’s in their best interest to accept a loan reinstatement.


Please do not hesitate to contact us to discuss your property situation.